Nigeria-South Africa diplomatic row exposes deeper tensions over xenophobia

Editors Pick

For Nigerians living in South Africa, the latest diplomatic disagreement is about more than an omitted livestream speech. Behind the public exchanges lie deeper concerns about their safety, the treatment of African migrants and the promises of solidarity between two countries whose relationship was forged during the struggle against apartheid.

Those concerns have resurfaced following a public confrontation involving Nigeria’s new high commissioner to South Africa, Femi Fani-Kayode, and officials in President Cyril Ramaphosa’s administration.

What began with Fani-Kayode’s complaint that his introduction and remarks were excluded from a presidential livestream has escalated into an exchange of accusations and a formal diplomatic intervention.

Yet, away from diplomatic corridors and social media arguments, ordinary people face something more immediate: uncertainty about their safety and the future of relations between two countries with much to lose from prolonged hostility.

A diplomatic row with deeper roots

On 13 November 2026, Fani-Kayode presented his credentials to Ramaphosa in Pretoria. He subsequently complained that his introduction and speech had been deliberately omitted from the presidential broadcast, describing the incident as disrespectful to Nigeria.

South African presidential spokesperson Vincent Magwenya rejected the allegation, saying the South African Broadcasting Corporation operated independently of the presidency. He also criticised the Nigerian envoy’s public response. The presidency subsequently published a separate video of Fani-Kayode’s speech.

The disagreement reached the Department of International Relations and Cooperation (DIRCO). On 17 November, its director-general, Zane Dangor, met Fani-Kayode and conveyed South Africa’s concerns about events following the credentials ceremony and the envoy’s subsequent social media remarks. DIRCO cited Article 41 of the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, emphasising the use of established diplomatic channels for official communication.

The Nigerian High Commission disputed descriptions of the meeting as a reprimand, maintaining that the engagement was cordial and constructive. Nigeria’s foreign ministry subsequently said it was reviewing a comprehensive report on the dispute and remained committed to diplomatic engagement.

The sharpness of the exchanges has exposed continuing strains in the relationship. For Nigerians concerned about attacks against their compatriots in South Africa, the controversy touches wounds far deeper than a broadcasting dispute.

The pain behind Nigeria’s anger

Nigeria’s frustration is closely connected to its history of supporting South Africa’s liberation from apartheid.

During the struggle, Nigeria provided financial assistance, scholarships and diplomatic support to South African liberation movements. Nigerian citizens also contributed to efforts to support the liberation struggle.

That history remains central to how many Nigerians understand the relationship.

Shola Shittu, a Nigerian citizen in Abuja, believes his country’s contribution to South Africa’s freedom makes the treatment of Nigerians living there particularly painful. He points to Nigeria’s financial contributions and educational support during apartheid.

Shittu believes the Nigerian high commissioner was justified in speaking up because he represents the interests of his country and its citizens.

However, the right of Nigerians to live without violence or harassment does not depend on a historical debt. It rests on the dignity and protection owed to every person.

In September, Nigerian officials put the number of Nigerians killed in South Africa since 2022 at 112, including 12 in 2026. These figures are attributed to Nigerian authorities; the circumstances and motives of individual deaths must be established separately rather than treating every killing as a confirmed xenophobic attack.

Nigeria has also facilitated the return of citizens following anti-migrant unrest.

For affected families, these are not simply diplomatic statistics. They concern relatives who left Nigeria in search of opportunities but found themselves confronting insecurity and uncertainty.

Ordinary people caught in political tensions

Nigerians living in South Africa include traders, students, professionals, business owners and families who have built their lives there. Many have little involvement in diplomatic arguments but cannot ignore hostility directed at their nationality.

Anti-immigrant campaigns and vigilante action have heightened concerns among foreign nationals. Migrant-owned businesses have been targeted and looted during recent unrest, deepening fears among African communities.

South African authorities have condemned xenophobic violence and maintained that criminal conduct must be addressed through lawful procedures. They have also raised concerns about offences allegedly involving some Nigerian nationals, including drug trafficking and cybercrime.

Allegations against individuals, however, cannot justify hostility towards an entire nationality. Those accused of crimes must face evidence-based investigations and due process, while migrants must be protected from intimidation and collective punishment.

When national stereotypes enter political arguments, ordinary Nigerians and South Africans who have no involvement in the dispute risk becoming targets of suspicion and resentment.

An Islamic call for justice and peaceful coexistence

The tensions also highlight the role Muslim scholars and religious institutions can play in defending human dignity and discouraging retaliation.

Reacting to the diplomatic disagreement, Imam Hafiz Sani Abdullahi, chief imam of Dakwa Central Mosque in Abuja, emphasised justice, the protection of human life and peaceful relations among communities, principles central to Islamic teachings.

Surah Al-Ma’idah 5:8 cautions believers against allowing hatred of others to lead them away from justice. Surah Al-Hujurat 49:13 teaches that humanity was created into different nations and tribes so that people may know one another.

These teachings offer a clear framework: anger over injustice must not become a justification for further injustice.

The Nigerian Supreme Council for Islamic Affairs (NSCIA), led by the Sultan of Sokoto, Muhammad Sa’ad Abubakar, has also emphasised unity and responsible conduct. In a communiqué following its General Assembly on 1 October 2026, the council cautioned against manipulating Islam to promote hatred. The communiqué did not address the South African diplomatic dispute.

Muslim scholars can help discourage retaliation, advocate accountability for attacks and mobilise support for affected families and vulnerable migrants.

Defending Nigerians against injustice does not require hostility towards the South African population. Equally, allegations involving individual Nigerians cannot justify attacks against other members of their community.

More than diplomatic relations at stake

Despite the tensions, the economic relationship remains important. South African businesses, including MTN, have substantial interests in Nigeria, while citizens of both countries depend on cross-border trade, employment and professional opportunities.

Both countries also play influential roles within the African Union and efforts to strengthen cooperation across the continent. A prolonged deterioration in relations could affect businesses, discourage investment and make life more difficult for their citizens.

A July 2026 visit to Abuja by South Africa’s Minister of International Relations and Cooperation, Ronald Lamola, had raised hopes of easing tensions. Both sides committed to reducing inflammatory rhetoric and addressing their differences through diplomacy. Nigeria sought stronger protection for its citizens and accountability for attacks, while South Africa reiterated its opposition to xenophobia and vigilante action.

The latest confrontation suggests those commitments require sustained work.

Diplomatic protocol matters, but the safety of people facing violence must remain central to the relationship. Neither government can afford to turn the dispute into a contest of national pride.

Rebuilding trust

For Nigerians who remember their country’s role in the anti-apartheid struggle, the current situation is deeply disappointing. For South Africans committed to African solidarity, attacks on migrants undermine the principles that helped sustain their own liberation.

The relationship cannot be repaired through diplomatic statements alone. South Africa must demonstrate that attacks against foreign nationals will be investigated and perpetrators held accountable. Allegations of abuse by security personnel also require credible investigation.

Nigeria, meanwhile, must protect its citizens through effective diplomacy, accessible consular support and responsible public communication.

Fani-Kayode’s livestream controversy may eventually fade. The fears of Nigerians living in South Africa will remain until protection and accountability become a lived reality.

The real measure of friendship between the two countries is whether ordinary people can live, work and go about their lives without being threatened because of where they come from.

- Advertisement -spot_img

More articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -spot_img

Latest article