By Maulana Ismail Moosa and Maulana Uwais Dockrat
Every time Muslims are subjected to another tragedy, we seem to react as though this is the first time such suffering has occurred. We express outrage, organise protests, issue statements and appeal to international institutions. We place our hopes in resolutions, court proceedings and diplomatic interventions, believing that justice may finally be around the corner.
Yet, as the suffering continues, we must ask ourselves an uncomfortable question: how many times must this cycle repeat before we begin questioning our approach?
The problem is not that Muslims lack outrage or concern for Palestine. The problem is that we often lack a coherent long-term vision for ending the conditions that allow such tragedies to occur repeatedly.
The illusion of international justice
Consider the enormous expectations placed upon the United Nations (UN), the International Court of Justice (ICJ) and other international institutions. Every resolution is celebrated, every hearing is followed with anticipation, and every legal development is presented as another step towards liberation.
These institutions can undoubtedly serve certain purposes. They can expose wrongdoing, establish legal findings, generate diplomatic pressure and potentially alleviate some suffering. However, their limitations must be understood.
The international order established after the Second World War was not designed in a political vacuum. It emerged from a particular distribution of global power, with its institutions reflecting the interests and privileges of the victorious powers.
The clearest example is the UN Security Council, where five permanent members possess veto powers that allow them to obstruct substantive resolutions, even when overwhelming international support exists.
The ICJ operates within a different legal framework, but enforcement of its judgments can ultimately encounter the same political obstacles, particularly when Security Council involvement becomes necessary.
We must therefore question the assumption that these institutions operate independently of the very power structures they are expected to challenge.
Rather than dismantling Western dominance, the international system has repeatedly helped preserve the existing distribution of global power.
A legal victory is not the same as liberation, and international recognition of an injustice does not automatically translate into the power to end it.
A century of Muslim suffering
Palestine is not an isolated tragedy. Over the past century, Muslim populations have experienced devastating persecution, occupation and mass violence across different regions.
Algeria endured brutal French colonial repression and mass killings. Bosnia witnessed ethnic cleansing and the Srebrenica genocide. Afghanistan suffered decades of invasion, occupation and warfare. Iraq experienced devastating wars, occupation and immense civilian suffering.
These conflicts differed in their causes, perpetrators and political circumstances. Nevertheless, they demonstrate a recurring reality: international condemnation alone has never been sufficient to guarantee the security of Muslim populations.
How many more tragedies must occur before we recognise that appealing to others for protection cannot constitute our entire political strategy?
The necessity of Muslim power
If Muslims wish to secure their future, they cannot remain permanently dependent upon external powers to defend their interests.
The long-term solution requires the development of genuine Muslim power: political authority, economic strength, intellectual independence, defensive capabilities, effective institutions and meaningful unity.
This is not simply about placing Muslim individuals in positions of influence within existing political structures. It is about developing the collective capacity to protect Muslim lives, determine our political direction and govern according to our own principles.
From an Islamic political perspective, this raises the question of the Khilāfah and the restoration of governance based upon the Sharīʿah of Allah.
For those who regard the Khilāfah as the long-term political objective, temporary engagement with existing international institutions need not be contradictory.
Using the ICJ, UN or other mechanisms to alleviate immediate suffering, prevent harm or secure particular benefits can be a legitimate short-term strategy.
The problem arises when these temporary mechanisms become substitutes for the long-term objective or when our engagement with them leads us to abandon that objective altogether.
There is a fundamental distinction between using a political mechanism and accepting the worldview upon which that mechanism operates.
The tool must remain a tool. It must not become the objective itself.
Which Islam liberated Al-Aqsa?
There is another dimension to this discussion that deserves serious attention.
Al-Aqsa first came under Muslim rule during the caliphate of ʿUmar ibn al-Khaṭṭāb رضي الله عنه. Centuries later, Ṣalāḥ al-Dīn al-Ayyūbī restored Muslim control of Jerusalem.
Neither belonged to a civilisation that understood Islam as merely a collection of private rituals or spiritual practices detached from public life.
Islam provided the foundations for law, governance, morality, political authority and collective responsibility.
It was understood as a complete Dīn, not simply a religion that needed to be redesigned to conform to the dominant ideologies of the time.
This historical reality raises an important question for contemporary Muslims.
We frequently speak about restoring Muslim strength, liberating Al-Aqsa and overcoming the political humiliation of the Muslim world. Yet, simultaneously, there are attempts to reinterpret Islam through the moral and political assumptions of liberalism, secularism and modernity.
Its teachings concerning morality, authority, governance and even Jihād are increasingly subjected to reinterpretation according to contemporary ideological preferences.
Jihād, properly understood within its established Sharʿī framework, is part of the Islamic tradition and cannot simply be erased because its principles conflict with prevailing political sensibilities.
If we progressively abandon the very worldview that historically shaped Islamic civilisation, what exactly are we hoping to restore?
Do not undermine the solution
The issue is ultimately much deeper than Palestine alone.
It concerns whether Muslims understand Islam as an objective truth that provides guidance for individual and collective life or whether Islam is to be continuously reshaped according to the demands of dominant political and moral systems.
If our vision of Muslim revival involves restoring political power while simultaneously surrendering the principles that should govern that power, we risk undermining the very revival we claim to support.
This does not mean rejecting every short-term political opportunity, legal mechanism or diplomatic intervention. Nor does it mean that political power alone will automatically produce justice. Power must itself be exercised with accountability and according to the principles of the Sharīʿah.
But it does mean recognising that immediate relief and long-term liberation are not necessarily the same objective.
We should pursue opportunities to alleviate suffering today without losing sight of the political future we believe Muslims should strive towards.
The question is not merely who will help the Muslims of Palestine today. It is what Muslims must become if they are to possess the capacity to protect themselves tomorrow.
And whatever answer we develop, it cannot begin by surrendering the very principles of Islam that we believe must guide our future.


