For millions of unemployed South Africans, the promise of a job can feel like a lifeline. But for some, that hope comes at a price. As job seekers struggle to find work, scammers are exploiting their desperation through fake recruitment opportunities, demanding money in exchange for jobs that may not even exist.
Jessie Swartz was an easy target for scammers. As one of South Africa’s millions of unemployed people seeking work, she scoured newspapers and online sites for opportunities.
Swartz told One Nation Media (ONM) that she came across an advertisement on Facebook from a woman claiming to earn money online by completing daily tasks on a platform.
“She had videos of the woman completing the tasks as well as proof of payment received for the work completed. She claimed to be an agent for the platform, and I thought, let’s give it a try,” said Swartz.
Believing the opportunity was legitimate, Swartz paid R400 to access the platform and its training materials.
“I paid R400 to get the training manuals and access to the platform. I registered and logged in to start doing tasks but soon realised that I won’t get paid because when I tried contacting the lady again, her phone just rang for two days and thereafter her number no longer existed. Turns out it was a dummy platform that allows you to do tasks but you never get paid,” she said.
R400 may not sound like a lot to some. To someone with no income, it is food for a week. It is taxi fare to a real interview. It is airtime to call family for help.
As job seekers like Swartz struggle to find work in a country with one of the highest unemployment rates in the world, scammers are exploiting their desperation through fake recruitment opportunities, demanding money in exchange for jobs that may not even exist.
For many unemployed South Africans, the promise of a job can feel like a lifeline.
Abdullah Mhlophe, an unemployed young man, told ONM: “The most difficult thing in finding employment is that in most cases you need connections; you have to know someone in order to get into the job or unless chances of not getting that job are very high. I have never felt like being an easy target to scammers because I am not willing anyway to secure a job in that manner.”
Scammers impersonating legitimate institutions
Teboho Thejane from the Department of Labour told ONM: “Yes, we have observed a number of scams on various social media platforms, others claiming even to be by our department.”
Being unemployed and spending most of one’s time at home can become a burden and take a toll on a person’s well-being. Seeing someone else share proof of how an online earning opportunity worked out for them can give another unemployed person hope and encourage them to try it.
Scammers study their victims
Thulisile Ndlovu, a specialist and community partnership leader at Harambee Youth Employment Accelerator, told ONM that the problem is widespread and that scammers often understand the circumstances of the people they target.
“Scams are very widespread and depend on each province; my feeling is that people who are scammers, they study people very, very well. They understand when they are desperate, what they need at that time,” said Ndlovu.
“Scammers often tailor their approaches to specific communities and provinces, understanding the different employment challenges faced by young people in urban and rural areas,” she said.
“Limited access to reliable employment information and a lack of professional networks make it difficult for some young people to identify legitimate opportunities,” Ndlovu added.
Ndlovu also warned: “Some advertisements promise interviews almost immediately after an application, with applicants sometimes being contacted on the same day and told to attend an interview the following morning.”
For someone desperate for work, such a response may appear encouraging. However, she advised job seekers to investigate the company, verify its location and consider whether the opportunity makes sense before travelling to an unfamiliar area.
Ndlovu cautioned job seekers against messages asking them to forward an opportunity to six other people to be considered, as well as requests to send personal information, such as identity numbers, through WhatsApp.
Recruitment scams do not always come from strangers. In some cases, scammers use the names of people or institutions that job seekers already trust to make their schemes appear legitimate.
“Even when an opportunity comes through someone a person knows, it is important to establish whether the job actually exists and whether the person making the offer has the authority to secure employment,” Ndlovu said.
She further warned: “Scammers may avoid traceable bank deposits and instead request cash-send payments that allow them to withdraw money without leaving an easily identifiable trail.”
Islam condemns the exploitation of the vulnerable
The job seeker believes the person offering the opportunity holds the power to change their financial circumstances. Exploiting that position to demand money, personal information or personal favours is not clever marketing. In Islamic terms, it is zulm — oppression.
In Islam, that R400 is not a small amount. It is someone else’s rizq — their provision — taken unjustly.
“Islam honours honest work, it does not excuse exploiting the jobless,” said Clare Russell, Executive Chef and Project Manager at Baked Academy.
A real alternative: Skills, not scams
Baked Academy, a skills development programme based in Benoni under the Guardian Institute, is one of the organisations trying to tackle unemployment and combat scams by providing opportunities for young people.
“We run a learnership programme once a year for unemployed youth who have disabilities and are from disadvantaged areas. In the course, they get a stipend for a whole year and then they do a fully accredited certificate in patisserie. Included in that course, they actually have a six-month internship as well at a bakery that we place them at,” Russell told ONM.
The programme aims to equip participants with skills that can help them enter the workplace, with some students potentially securing employment at the bakeries where they complete their internships.
The academy also offers a diploma in patisserie for people who want to develop their skills and start their own businesses.
“Students that are really committed to this as a career path, they may even be able to secure employment from the places we’ve put them at after they’ve done this course. And then we’ve also got a diploma in patisserie course, which people pay to come and join. This course, we teach them how to become self-sufficient and how to start their own businesses from home. So, in that way, they won’t obviously get scammed because they’re starting their own businesses; they’re bringing in their own income. And so far, have been very successful with that, Alhamdulillah,” said Russell.
What should a job seeker do?
“People should check company websites, look for official contact details and use verified telephone numbers to establish whether an opportunity is legitimate,” Ndlovu said.
And if things do go wrong, “They must report to the SAPS and open a case of fraud,” said Thejane.
Red flags to watch for:
- You are asked to pay for training, manuals, placement or “activation” before you start. A legitimate employer should not charge you to secure a job. Be particularly wary of payments demanded in exchange for guaranteed employment.
- You are contacted the same day and told to attend an interview the next morning in an unfamiliar area. Haste can be a tool of deception. Islam teaches tathabbut: verify before you act.
- You are asked to forward the advert to six people to qualify. This is a warning sign of potentially fraudulent recruitment, not a credible employment requirement.
- You are asked to send your ID number or bank details via WhatsApp. Your identity is an amanah — a trust. Do not hand sensitive information to unverified contacts.
- You are asked to pay via Cash Send or eWallet. Requests for payments that are difficult to recover or trace should raise concerns, particularly when the recipient’s identity cannot be verified.
Ultimately, unemployment should not mean that people have to sacrifice their money, personal information or dignity in exchange for the possibility of securing a job.
While the search for employment can be frustrating and financially draining, verifying an opportunity before committing to it could prevent job seekers from becoming victims of another scam.
And for those who run these schemes: no amount of “proof of payment” videos, religious posts or claims of helping people can make haram earnings halal.


